Can you suggest a moderately priced hotel near Times Square that includes parking?

Looking to spend a Friday & Saturday evening this January in the city and will need to park a car. Hoping to keep the cost under $450 total. I know it can be done but I don't know if I can trust the reviews I've read for some of the hotels. (for example, The Milford Plaza...half of the reviews say it's great, the other half say it's horrible) One room, two adults.